Finance Commission of India (FCI)

The Finance Commission is a quasi-judicial body created by the President of India as per the Constitution. It is not a permanent institution, and the President appoints the Commission every five years, or sooner if deemed necessary. Its main function is to provide recommendations on the allocation of financial resources between the Union Government and the States.

Constitutional Provisions

Articles 280 and 281 of the Constitution of India govern the Finance Commission:

• Article 280: Establishes the Finance Commission.
  
• Article 281: Deals with the recommendations made by the Finance Commission.
  

Composition of the Finance Commission

The Commission is comprised of a Chairman and four other members, all appointed by the President. The tenure of the Chairman and members is specified by the President, and they are eligible for reappointment.

Qualifications of the Members

The Parliament determines the qualifications of the members. The Finance Commission Act of 1951 specifies that:

• The Chairman should have experience in public affairs.
  
• The four other members should include:
  
  • A High Court judge or someone qualified to be appointed as one.
    
  • An individual with specialized knowledge in finance and government accounts.
    
  • Someone with extensive experience in financial matters and administration.
    
  • A person with expertise in economics.
    

Functions of the Finance Commission

The Finance Commission is tasked with advising the President on:

1. The distribution of net tax proceeds between the Centre and the States, as well as the allocation of shares among States.
   
2. The principles governing the grants-in-aid from the Centre to the States from the Consolidated Fund of India.
   
3. Measures to augment a State’s Consolidated Fund to assist local governments (Panchayats and Municipalities) based on the State Finance Commission’s recommendations.
   
4. Other fiscal matters referred by the President.
   

Report of the Finance Commission

The Commission submits its report to the President, who then presents it to Parliament, along with an explanatory memorandum detailing the actions taken based on its recommendations.

Key Aspects of the Finance Commission’s Recommendations

The recommendations generally cover:

1. Vertical Devolution: Distribution of Central tax revenues among the States.
   
2. Horizontal Distribution: Allocation of resources among States, ensuring equitable development.
   
3. Grants-in-aid: Additional transfers to specific States or sectors requiring financial assistance for reforms or improvement.
   

Nature of Recommendations

The recommendations of the Finance Commission are advisory and non-binding on the government. The Union Government has the discretion to implement or reject these recommendations.

Role of the Finance Commission

The Commission plays a pivotal role in India’s fiscal structure by:

• Equitably distributing resources between the Centre and the States, considering factors like population, area, and economic disparity.
  
• Promoting social welfare by recommending grants-in-aid for States lacking sufficient revenue for essential services.
  
• Empowering State Governments by increasing their financial autonomy.
  
• Strengthening local governance by recommending ways to augment local bodies’ resources.
  
• Facilitating federalism by encouraging cooperation between the Centre and States.
  
• Ensuring fiscal discipline by promoting sustainable financial management at both levels of government.
  
• Encouraging reforms by tying financial incentives to specific milestones.
  

Fiscal Federalism and the Finance Commission

Fiscal federalism involves the division of financial resources and responsibilities between different levels of government. The Finance Commission’s role is crucial in balancing financial imbalances between the Centre and States, promoting fiscal autonomy, and ensuring equitable development among States. It fosters cooperative federalism, where all government levels work together toward common goals.

Challenges and Limitations

The Finance Commission faces several challenges, such as:

• Data gaps and quality issues, as official data is often incomplete or outdated.
  
• Political pressures from various stakeholders with conflicting interests.
  
• Imbalance between resources and responsibilities, as the Commission’s mandate is broad but its resources are limited.
  
• Overlap with the GST Council, especially concerning tax revenue sharing.
  
• Limited influence over local self-government as its recommendations regarding local bodies depend on State Finance Commission inputs.
  
• Implementation challenges, as its recommendations are advisory and not enforceable.
  

Future Recommendations

• Making the Commission permanent, as suggested by the PV Rajamannar Committee.
  
• Strengthening its analytical capacity by improving data collection and methodological rigor.
  
• Enhancing consultation and communication strategies to increase stakeholder engagement.
  
• Promoting competitive federalism, encouraging States to adopt best practices.
  
• Addressing emerging fiscal issues such as the GST implementation, the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, and challenges related to climate change and digital transformation.
  

Conclusion

The Finance Commission of India (FCI) is a cornerstone of India’s fiscal framework, ensuring the fair distribution of financial resources between the Union and States. As India progresses economically and socially, the Commission’s role remains vital in promoting balanced growth and fiscal stability. Addressing the challenges it faces will further enhance its capacity to support India’s diverse regional needs and foster a more equitable federal system.

---

15th Finance Commission of India

• Constitution: Formed in November 2017, chaired by NK Singh, its recommendations cover the 2021-2026 period.
  

16th Finance Commission of India

• Constitution: Formed on December 31, 2023, with Arvind Panagariya as Chairman. The Commission is set to release recommendations by October 31, 2025, for the 2026-2031 period.
  

Key aspects include:

1. Distribution of tax proceeds between the Centre and States.
   
2. Principles governing grants-in-aid to States.
   
3. Measures to augment State resources for Panchayats and Municipalities.
   

Reviewing disaster management funding under the Disaster Management Act of 2005.